In 1989 the New York Times wrote the
following about The Virginian:
"The 1902 novel, ancestor
of the classic western, turned out to be not only corny and flag-waving
but also intolerant and reactionary by today's standards. The story
includes sentimental lectures on Americanism that sound like a jingoist
speech by Theodore Roosevelt, to whom the book is dedicated."
God forbid that a book, in the eyes of
the Times, should be “flag waving” or view America as an exceptional
place. But credit must be given where credit is
due. The Times was right; The Virginian does all that and
more. In fact, it established the rugged, individualistic,
self-dependent, cowboy as a cultural icon in our society.
Indeed, it can be said that the western fictional genre began the day
this book was published; and it was the best selling book of its day.
You would be hard pressed to find a
better endorsement for any book than to have the New York Times condemn
it as containing… dare I say the words… “sentimental lectures on
Americanism.” You would also be hard pressed to find a better
western novel. Zane Gray, Louis L’Amour, Larry McMurtry, and
all the others began right here.
The First True Western
Novel
Condemned by the New York Times
Now Available to You